Coral Bay Cafe

Nestled in the charming neighborhood of Staten Island, Coral Bay Cafe offers an authentic Italian dining experience that beautifully celebrates the flavors of the sea. This beloved Italian restaurant specializes in fresh, expertly prepared seafood dishes alongside classic Italian favorites, making each visit a true culinary delight. Located at 722 Rockaway St, Coral Bay Cafe invites guests to enjoy a cozy, romantic atmosphere that feels like a hidden gem—perfect for both intimate dinners and relaxed nights out.

The menu at Coral Bay Cafe reads like a love letter to Italian seafood cuisine. From the moment you taste their signature Seafood Tower, brimming with fresh oysters, clams on the half shell, and jumbo shrimp, you know you’re in for something special. The Fried Calamari appetizer is a crowd favorite, boasting the perfect balance of tender, tender calamari coated in a golden, crispy exterior that crunches delightfully with every bite. Seafood lovers will revel in dishes such as Sea Bass, Stuffed Filet of Sole Oregenata with Crabmeat, and the indulgent Scungilli over Linguine in a Hot Sauce, each prepared to showcase the freshest flavors of the ocean complemented by rich, authentic Italian sauces that leave a lasting impression.

For meat enthusiasts, the restaurant offers luscious options like Filet Mignon & Jumbo Shrimp, Veal Saltimbocca, and a perfectly cooked New York Strip Dine to Perfection. Vegetarians can also indulge in the creamy, comforting Gnocchi Napoletana or the vibrant Mozzarella Caprese salad, which brings together fresh mozzarella, juicy beefsteak tomatoes, roasted peppers, and olives drizzled with extra virgin olive oil—a refreshing prelude to the meal.

The dining atmosphere complements the culinary journey with a warm, inviting ambiance that is both cozy and refined. Many diners note the exceptional service, with attentive staff who make every effort to enhance your experience. Whether seated inside or enjoying the scenic view outside on a pleasant day, the setting at Coral Bay Cafe is enhanced by its quiet residential location near the bay, creating a relaxing yet sophisticated environment.

Sweet endings at Coral Bay Cafe are just as thoughtfully curated. The Pistachio Cake offers a delicate balance of nutty richness and moist texture, perfect for wrapping up your meal. Their drink menu features house favorites like the refreshing Red Sangria and expertly crafted Margarita, to elevate your dining experience with a splash of zest and complexity.

Guests consistently praise Coral Bay Cafe for its outstanding food quality and genuine hospitality. Samantha Taranto highlights the “topnotch” service and the flawlessly cooked calamari, while Jonathan Soto and his fiancée raved about the “amazing” time spent, noting the knowledgeable waitstaff and delicious dishes. Others appreciate the restaurant’s romantic and cozy vibe, perfect for a special night out without breaking the bank.

While some advise caution regarding certain specials, the consensus remains that sticking to the well-curated menu promises delicious satisfaction. Despite a rare delay in service reported by one guest, the exceptional quality of the food makes every minute worth the wait, especially when dining right off the beach with the salty sea air enhancing each bite.

Coral Bay Cafe is more than just an Italian restaurant; it’s a culinary retreat where every dish tells a story of freshness, tradition, and meticulous craftsmanship. For those seeking a memorable meal infused with the vibrant tastes of Italy’s coastlines, it’s easy to see why Coral Bay Cafe has become a cherished favorite in Staten Island.